Rendition-US Court Fails Rule of Law

Posted on at


US court has refused freedom of information requests made by the United Kingdom’s All-Party Parliamentary Group on Extraordinary Rendition. At a public hearing of the European Parliament concerning the involvement of European Union States in secret detention and rendition, Special Rapporteur on human rights and counter-terrorism Ben Emmerson saidthe decision by the US District Court of Columbia “flies in the face of the principles of best practice for the oversight of intelligence services. The All-Party Group has rightly been pressing for independent oversight of intelligence services, pressing for real answers from the US Department of Defense, the CIA and other US Government agencies on this important issue,” Mr. Emmerson said.


In 2008, the Group made 43 separate requests under the US Freedom of Information Act concerning UK involvement in the US extraordinary renditions program. The US Government refused the requests on the grounds of a statutory exception which allows US intelligence agencies to refuse requests from ‘foreign government entities.’ Mr. Emmerson stressed the decision is “surprising because it seems to be based on a fundamental misunderstanding of the constitution of the United Kingdom and of the universal separation of powers doctrine. “The All-Party Parliamentary Group on Extraordinary Rendition is an institution of Parliament not the Government. It is wholly independent of Government and is a model of democratic oversight.” 


The US Government of course has been less than forthcoming on any request related to the dubious rendition program. Although acknowledged to be illegal under US and international standards, Washington has played a game of Scrabble changing words and letters to obfuscate requests, the law as well as the truth. US Courts have largely not played an effective role consistent with the Constitution and the Rule of Law. See our Blog for Video Report -


In addition, Mr. Emmerson emphasized the need for transparency and accountability, underlining that “refusing to disclose key information about alleged participation of UK officials in extraordinary rendition runs the risk of promoting impunity for state officials of the UK who may have been party to grave human rights violations.The unjustified maintenance of secrecy, on dubious legal grounds, only delays efforts at establishing the truth.”


Ambassador Muhamed Sacirbey - FOLOW mo @MuhamedSacirbey

Facebook-Become a Fan at “Diplomatically Incorrect”

Twitter – Follow us @DiplomaticallyX


See more at our Popular Video Blogs & Current News Event



About the author


"Voice of the Global Citizen"- Diplomatically Incorrect ( provide film and written reports on issues reflecting diplomatic discourse and the global citizen. Ambassador Muhamed Sacirbey (@MuhamedSacirbey) is former Foreign Minister Ambassador of Bosnia & Herzegovina at the United Nations. "Mo" is also signatory of the Rome Conference/Treaty establishing the International…

Subscribe 0